Does a marketplace for 4G phones inactive exist? Xiaomi thinks so, truthful it released the Redmi Note 17 4G. We’ve already looked astatine the artillery beingness and charging tests of its 5G sibling and promised to comparison the 2 successful a abstracted nonfiction – this is that article. We will, of course, comparison it with different models too, but which ones?
We tried to prime retired mostly 4G phones for this comparison, however, we conscionable don’t reappraisal that galore 4G phones – so, we had nary prime but to enactment the Redmi Note 17 4G against a radical of mostly 5G phones.
Redmi Note 17 4G retail package
As promised, we commencement with the examination betwixt the 4G and 5G versions of the Redmi Note 17. They person mostly the same hardware but for the chipset – the 4G exemplary gets a 6nm Snapdragon 6s 4G Gen 2, portion the 5G exemplary gets a 4nm Snapdragon 4 Gen 4. Both phones person 7,700mAh Si/C batteries with 45W charging and immense 6.99” displays (1080p+, 120Hz).
Surprisingly, it is the modem that hurts the Redmi Note 17 4G the astir – the telephone clip is importantly worse than the 5G model. Video playback is besides rather a spot shorter and the web browsing clip is an hr down. So, adjacent if you don’t attraction astir 5G connectivity, you should person a bully look astatine the terms quality betwixt the 2 models. The 5G mentation offers longer artillery beingness and somewhat amended performance.
This clip around, Xiaomi skipped the 4G Pro model, but determination was 1 past procreation – the Redmi Note 15 Pro 4G. The combo of a smaller surface (6.77”) and a smaller artillery (6,500mAh) works retired to an Active Use Score that comes adjacent to the Note 17 4G. However, the Helio G200 Ultra (6nm) chipset didn’t bash large successful the gaming and web browsing tests.
The Redmi Note 17 Pro is lone disposable successful 5G signifier and portion it has a larger artillery of 8,340mAh than the vanilla Note 17 models (+640mAh), its Active Use Score is little than some phones.
The Redmi Note 15 4G and 5G had 6,000mAh and 5,520mAh batteries, respectively, paired with 33W and 45W charging. In different words, the aged 4G exemplary got a larger artillery that had slower charging than its 5G sibling. This year’s Note 17 4G and 5G are connected par successful some respects.
After a speedy 15-minute charge, some phones were astatine 23%. At the 30-minute mark, the 2 phones were inactive connected the aforesaid level (save for immoderate rounding error). What’s absorbing is that the aged Redmi Note 15 Pro 4G didn’t propulsion ahead, adjacent though it has a smaller artillery (6,500mAh vs. 7,700mAh) and the aforesaid 45W complaint rating.
Meanwhile, the caller Pro (5G) has a bigger artillery (+8%) and faster charging (+49%). These 2 equilibrium retired and the Pro exemplary is connected astir the aforesaid complaint level arsenic the 2 vanilla Redmi Note 17 phones. You whitethorn deliberation that 8% and 49% are not balanced, but the world is that the highest charging standing isn’t what determines complaint clip – the complaint curve does that.
The Redmi Note 17 4G supports 45W charging
This brings america to the 3rd tab – the Redmi Note 17 4G needed an hr and a fractional for a afloat charge. The 5G exemplary got determination 3 minutes quicker, but that is wrong the borderline of mistake – we don’t deliberation that the antithetic chipsets had immoderate interaction here.
The Redmi Note 17 Pro (8,340mAh, 67W) bushed the Realme 16T (8,000mAh, 45W) to the decorativeness line, contempt having a bigger battery. We deliberation the vanilla Note 17 models would person benefited from 67W charging enactment excessively arsenic an hr and a fractional feels sluggish.
The Redmi Note 17 4G uses a Snapdragon 6s 4G Gen 2 chipset – this is really a downgrade from the Note 15 4G, which had a Helio G100 Ultra, which benchmarked amended than the Snapdragon.
So, this is simply a downgrade or, if we’re being generous, a side-grade. The aged exemplary besides had a 108MP main camera (1/1.67”) that was replaced by a basal 50MP module (1/2.76”). And sure, the caller exemplary has a larger 6.99” show (vs. 6.77”), but whether you see having a immense telephone (that is 79.1mm wide!) an upgrade oregon not is up to you.
Here’s what we deliberation – the larger artillery capableness connected the Redmi Note 17 4G gives it amended artillery life, which is simply a coagulated upgrade. But the 5G mentation lasts adjacent longer and some complaint astatine the aforesaid velocity (which we inactive deliberation could person been improved).
The planetary pricing of the Note 17 4G is $250, portion the 5G variant is $50 more. In Europe, the quality successful MSRPs is €100, but aft discounts you are looking astatine €230 for a 4/128GB 4G and €300 for a 6/128GB 5G exemplary (an 8% disconnected coupon got that down to €276). In India, the 4G exemplary didn’t adjacent launch, there’s only the 5G model.
The terms spread betwixt the 4G and the 5G phones is not small, but we deliberation it’s worthy it for the amended show and longer artillery beingness of the Redmi Note 17 5G. And if you don’t similar that one, you tin ever conscionable get the Poco M8 Pro. The 4G exemplary feels retired of spot and retired of time.
English (US) ·